KUALA LUMPUR: The High Court here today upheld the three-year prison sentence and a RM50,000 fine imposed on former Sabah Infrastructure Development Minister Datuk Peter Anthony for forging a letter for the purpose of cheating.
Judge Datuk Ahmad Bache made the decision after dismissing Peter's appeal to set aside the conviction and sentence imposed by the Sessions Court on May 26 last year..
The court also allowed an application by lawyer S. Devanandan, representing Peter, to stay the execution of the jail sentence and conviction pending the disposal of an appeal at the Court of Appeal.
Peter was charged in his capacity as managing director of Syarikat Asli Jati Sdn Bhd with forging a letter from the office of the UMS Deputy Vice-Chancellor, dated June 9, 2014, by inserting a false statement with the intention of using it for fraudulent purposes.
The offence was allegedly committed at the office of the Prime Minister's principal private secretary at the Perdana Putra building in Putrajaya between June 13 and August 21, 2014.
However, the Parti Kesejahteraan Demokratik Masyarakat (KDM) president paid the fine.
"The court also found that there was no reason for these witnesses to lie and support each other because they were victims of being deceived and used by the appellant (Peter). Their testimony was consistent that they thought P2 (letter of support) was for the benefit of UMS for the purpose of 'smart partnership' and not for their personal interests," he said.
He said SP8 and SP9 had obtained a blank letterhead from the former vice-chancellor of Universiti Malaysia Sabah (UMS) Professor Datuk Dr Mohd Harun Abdullah (SP1) and then SP3 typed a draft letter of support, but the title on the letterhead was not typed by SP3.
"The information also shows that several letters of support have been made by the appellant and SP8, SP9 and SP3 have also given letters of support as requested by the appellant. These three witnesses then met Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak who was then the prime minister and finance minister to minute the letters of support," he said.
Judge Ahmad said the session court judge (HMS) was not wrong and the court also agreed with the judge's finding that the appellant falsified documents, despite knowing that the project was made through an open tender.
"The court agrees that the appellant's defence was an afterthought which ultimately brought disaster to the appellant. After examining all the available evidence and taking into account the arguments of both parties and examining the exhibits, the court agrees with the trial judge's findings that the defense failed to raise reasonable doubt and therefore, the court dismisses the appellant's appeal," said the judge.
Earlier, Devanandan requested that the court reduce the prison sentence and fine imposed by the trial judge which was considered excessive considering the appellant's contribution to the people of Sabah.
"The appellant was a minister in Sabah before being accused in court and he contributed a lot to the people of the state in addition to providing projects and programmes for UMS students to undergo training at the appellant's company.
"The court also needs to consider the factor of the appellant who is a first offender," said the lawyer who also requested that the court allow a stay of execution of the prison sentence pending an appeal at the Court of Appeal.
Meanwhile, deputy public prosecutor Datuk Wan Shaharuddin Wan Ladin said there was no denying that the appellant was an educated person and had contributed a lot for Sabah and that matter had been taken into account by the trial judge before sentencing.
"The fine of RM50,000 is just a pittance for the appellant. Therefore, I request that the prison sentence and the fine be maintained because it is not too high," he said.
Wan Shaharuddin also did not object to the lawyer's application for a stay of the execution of the prison sentence because the appellant never caused any problems during the proceedings of his case in the Sessions Court.
"The appellant must be given the opportunity to appeal and we do not object to the lawyer's application," he said.
-- BERNAMA
Bernama
Tue Apr 18 2023
Judge Datuk Ahmad Bache said Datuk Peter Anthony failed to raise a reasonable doubt in the prosecutions case. - BERNAMA
PM Anwar saksikan pertukaran enam MoU antara Malaysia dan Uzbekistan
Perdana Menteri Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim menyaksikan pertukaran enam MoU antara Malaysia dan Uzbekistan di sini pada Sabtu, untuk kerjasama dalam pelbagai bidang antara kedua-dua negara.
Tahap keselamatan balai, tempat kunjungan ramai perlu ditingkatkan - Lee Lam Thye
Tahap keselamatan di semua balai polis dan tempat-tempat yang sering dikunjung ramai perlu ditingkatkan segera.
Kontraktor, operator menara telekomunikasi perlu jalin kerjasama - Fahmi
Menteri Komunikasi Fahmi Fadzil meminta kontraktor dan operator menara telekomunikasi supaya sentiasa berhubung dan bekerjasama bagi memastikan segala permasalahan dapat ditangani segera.
Lee Zii Jia melangkah ke akhir Terbuka Thailand
Lee Zii Jia layak ke perlawanan akhir Terbuka Thailand dengan menewaskan pemain pilihan kelapan kejohanan dari Taiwan Chou Tien Chen.
10 Berita Pilihan - (18 Mei 2024)
Antara pelbagai berita dalam dan luar negara yang disiarkan di Astro AWANI, berikut adalah yang paling menjadi tumpuan sepanjang hari ini.
Suspek serangan Balai Polis Ulu Tiram tiada kaitan kumpulan pengganas - KPN
Polis mengenal pasti suspek yang menyerang Balai Polis Ulu Tiram semalam tiada kaitan dengan kumpulan pengganas.
Filem aksi 'The Experts' angkat tema kekeluargaan
Unsur kekeluargaan menjadi taruhan filem aksi bertemakan rompakan "The Experts" bagi membezakannya daripada filem bergenre sama yang pernah dibawa ke layar perak sebelum ini.
Malaysia jadi negara contoh ‘best practice’ perkembangan digital, teknologi AI
Malaysia dijadikan salah satu negara contoh yang mempunyai best practice bagi memastikan aspirasi digital dan teknologi Kecerdasan Buatan (AI) dapat dijayakan.
KBS mahu pencarian bakat sukan diteruskan di peringkat negeri
Kementerian Belia dan Sukan (KBS) mahu program pencarian dan pembangunan bakat dilakukan secara berterusan di peringkat negeri khususnya bagi sukan yang mampu menyumbang pingat di pentas antarabangsa.
Kad Diskaun Khas Menu Rahmah tawar diskaun 40 peratus belian barangan keperluan perniagaan
Beban peniaga makanan menyediakan Menu Rahmah berikutan kenaikan harga barang boleh diatasi, apabila mereka memohon dan menggunakan Kad Diskaun Khas Menu Rahmah.
Peter Anthony dibenar kemuka bukti baharu dalam rayuan akhir
Mahkamah Rayuan membenarkan permohonan bekas Menteri Pembangunan Infrastruktur Sabah Datuk Peter Anthony, untuk mengemukakan bukti baharu dalam rayuan akhirnya.
Oswald sifatkan Pandikar Amin umpama 'cacing kepanasan'
Oswald berkata, kenyataan Pandikar Amin seolah-olah terpesong daripada topik utama yang disuarakan Peter sebelum ini.
Pengurusan kes untuk rayuan Peter Anthony ditetapkan 28 Julai
Penolong Kanan Pendaftar Mahkamah Rayuan Nurul Azrina Mohamed Yusof menetapkan tarikh pengurusan kes berikutnya itu, disebabkan rekod rayuan belum dapat disiapkan.
Peter Anthony fail rayuan akhir ketepikan sabitan dan hukuman
Ini adalah rayuan terakhirnya kerana kes yang bermula di Mahkamah Sesyen, rayuan akan berakhir di Mahkamah Rayuan.
Sabitan dan hukuman penjara tiga tahun, denda RM50,000 terhadap Peter Anthony kekal
Mahkamah mengekalkan hukuman penjara tiga tahun serta denda RM50,000 terhadap bekas Menteri Pembangunan Infrastruktur Sabah Datuk Peter Anthony.
Riduan kekal Ahli Parlimen Tenom, mahkamah tolak petisyen pilihan raya Peter
Riduan Rubin mengekalkan kedudukan beliau sebagai Ahli Parlimen Bebas bagi kawasan Tenom.
Keputusan rayuan Peter Anthony terhadap sabitan dan hukuman 18 April
Mahkamah menetapkan 18 April untuk keputusan rayuan Peter Anthony bagi mengetepikan sabitan dan hukuman penjara tiga tahun serta denda RM50,000 terhadapnya.
KDM umum beri sokongan penuh kepada Hajiji sebagai KM Sabah
Parti Kesejahteraan Demokratik Masyarakat (KDM) mengumumkan memberi sokongan penuh kepada kepimpinan Datuk Seri Hajiji Noor sebagai Ketua Menteri Sabah.
Rayuan Peter Anthony terhadap sabitan dan hukuman didengar 15 Mac
Rayuan Peter Anthony bagi mengetepikan sabitan dan hukuman penjara serta denda yang dijatuhkan terhadapnya bagi kesalahan menggunakan dokumen palsu, akan didengar 15 Mac ini.
Politik Sabah: Hajiji sudah tiada lagi majoriti - KDM
Datuk Peter Anthony berkata, di bawah Perkara 7 (1) Perlembagaan Negeri Sabah, Hajiji yang juga ADUN Sulaman perlu meletak jawatan serta-merta.